How to Choose Your First Home Server Hardware: A Practical Guide
Choosing your first home server starts with understanding your needs, your budget, and how much room you want to leave for future upgrades. Whether you’re leaning toward a compact mini PC, a full-sized tower, or even a rackmount setup, your goal is to find the sweet spot between performance, efficiency, and expandability.
Choosing a Form Factor: What Fits Your Life?
Mini PCs (1L Form Factor)
Great for: First-timers, low-power tasks, quiet home setups
Mini PCs are small, quiet, and energy-efficient—perfect for starting out. Models like the Lenovo ThinkCentre M920q or HP EliteDesk 800 G5 Mini can be found second-hand for around €200-350 and pack surprising power into a tiny footprint.
Pros:
- Very low power usage (~10-35W idle)
- Virtually silent
- Affordable and easy to tuck away
- Decent performance for most basic homelab tasks
Cons:
- Limited upgrade options
- Not ideal for heavy virtualization or GPU tasks
- Few expansion slots
Read more about Mini PCs for homelab
Tower/Desktop Systems
Great for: Tinkerers, gamers, power users
If you’re planning to build your own or upgrade over time, towers offer the most flexibility. You can choose every component yourself, upgrade as needed, and run just about any workload.
Pros:
- Full control over parts
- Room for powerful CPUs, GPUs, and lots of storage
- Easy to cool and maintain
Cons:
- Takes up space
- Uses more power
- Costs more upfront
Compare tower and rack options
Rack Servers
Great for: Advanced users, enterprise simulations, high-density labs
Used rack servers like the Dell R720 or HP DL380 G9 offer a ton of power and features at a good price—but they’re noisy and power-hungry. They’re best suited for serious lab environments.
Pros:
- Lots of RAM, CPU cores, and storage capacity
- Enterprise features like IPMI, hot-swap bays, and redundancy
- Ideal for large-scale or 24/7 workloads
Cons:
- Loud
- Heavy and large
- Requires a rack and lots of cooling
ARM Boards (Raspberry Pi, Orange Pi, etc.)
Great for: Learning, hobby projects, ultra-low-power tasks
If you’re experimenting or just want something super cheap and quiet, ARM boards like Raspberry Pi are fun and functional.
Pros:
- Extremely energy-efficient (~5-15€/year)
- Affordable and silent
- Great learning platform
Cons:
- Not very powerful
- Not ideal for media servers or virtualization
- Some software limitations
The Real Cost: Thinking Beyond the Sticker Price
Upfront Hardware Costs
- Entry Level (€200-400): Used mini PCs, ARM boards, basic towers
- Mid-Range (€400-800): Newer mini PCs, DIY towers, refurbished rack servers
- High-End (€800+): Fully custom builds, enterprise rack servers, future-proof setups
Annual Power Costs (at €0.25/kWh)
- ARM (10W): ~€22
- Mini PC (25W): ~€55
- Tower (100W): ~€219
- Rack Server (300W): ~€657
Matching Hardware to Your Goals
Virtualization
Want to run multiple virtual machines? Tower systems and rack servers are your best bet thanks to higher core counts and more RAM. Newer mini PCs (with 8th gen Intel or better) can still run a handful of lightweight VMs well.
Virtualization hardware comparisons
Media Streaming and Transcoding
Transcoding for Jellyfin or Plex? Look for Intel integrated graphics (UHD 770/780) or dedicated GPUs like the Intel Arc A380. Intel still leads in this space, especially for HEVC content.
Guide to media transcoding hardware
Network Services (DNS, VPN, etc.)
These are light tasks, and any modern system can handle them. Just make sure your server has enough Ethernet ports and possibly support for 2.5GbE or 10GbE if you’re thinking ahead.
How Much Can You Grow?
Mini PCs
Upgrade RAM and SSDs, maybe even dual NVMe if you pick the right model like the Lenovo M920q. That said, don’t expect to add GPUs or more storage bays.
Towers
Full upgrade freedom—CPU, GPU, drives, RAM. If you build smart, you won’t need to replace your system for years.
Rack Servers
Maximum expandability: multiple CPUs, lots of RAM, many storage bays. Ideal for big projects or shared setups.
Best Choices by User Type
New to Homelabs?
- Start With: Used mini PC (Lenovo M920q or HP G5 Mini)
- Why: Quiet, cheap, simple to set up, low risk
- Budget: €200-350
Enthusiasts and DIYers
- Start With: Custom AMD AM5 tower build
- Why: Control, upgradeability, and performance
- Budget: €500-800
Simulating Business/Enterprise Setups
- Start With: Refurbished rack server (Dell R720)
- Why: Enterprise features, scale, realism
- Budget: €400-800 (plus space and cooling needs)
Low Power & Tinkerers
- Start With: Raspberry Pi 5 or Orange Pi 5
- Why: Super low energy use, great for learning
- Budget: €100-200
Final Tips
- Start small. You can always upgrade later.
- Mind the power bill. A little efficiency goes a long way.
- Pick something popular. It’s easier to get help from the community.
- Don’t chase raw power. Stability and reliability matter more.
- Think 2-3 years ahead. Plan for the long run.
No matter which route you take, 2025 is a great year to dive into home servers. There’s affordable, powerful hardware at every level—just find what fits your goals and go for it.